So, my first point is that it's a good thing direct services are
usually not provided by state agencies. State employees I've
encountered are generally competent, compassionate and responsive but
they do receive reasonable financial compensation paid for by state and
federal taxpayers. Except for some exceptions like Partners in Service
(PINS), folks don't usually make donations to state agencies or their
programs. Nor do state agencies rely on volunteers in any significant
way. So, taxpayers may get what we pay for, but we pay for everything
we get.
Last year's annual cash operating expenses for the Good Samaritan Haven
(the "shelter" that was recommended) in 2008 was $143,242. Of this,
about 54 percent came from a combination of state and federal programs.
The remaining 46 percent, or $68,000, came from private donations from
churches, individuals, businesses, United Way, and private foundations.
In addition, volunteers contributed over 7,500 hours. The Haven is
staffed every night -- 365 nights a year -- from 6 p.m. until 7 a.m. by
volunteers. Volunteers provide other services as well. Families,
church groups and service organizations pay for, prepare, and deliver
over 5,000 hot and nutritious meals per year on every day but Christmas
and Thanksgiving when local churches offer special holiday meals for
all in need. Television cable services are donated. Trash removal
services are donated. It's not a stretch to value volunteer services
and food at well over $100,000 per year.
So, Good Samaritan Haven easily provides over $250,000 worth of
services at a cost to state and federal taxpayers of about $80,000. A
state agency simply could not do this. In short, thankfully there are
many others like Marie Leotta who contribute their time, energy, skills
and money to help folks in need.
Second, the recommendation to call Good Samaritan Haven (not shelter)
was a good one. Ms. Leotta's dismay that "all she (the social worker)
could recommend is an overnight shelter" was badly misplaced. Although
it is true that the Haven is only open at night, there is a full-time
staff that helps Haven guests find jobs (if needed), financial
assistance, and safe and affordable permanent housing. Guests are
welcome to stay so long as they are working toward self-sufficiency.
The average stay at the Haven is about 25 days. The Haven has
accommodations for men, women and families. The three dogs wouldn't
have fazed Haven staff and arrangements would have been made to keep
the dogs warm, safe and fed.
Right now, the accommodations at the Haven are a bit limited as an
addition is being built and renovations are being made to the existing
building. But, the Haven and the Lajeunesse Construction have arranged
the scheduling so that the Haven can remain open while the work is
being done. The Haven has operated every day for the past 22 years and
it was simply time for additional work such as a sprinkler system,
increased energy efficiency, improved handicapped access, and an
addition so everyone can dine together.
Nonetheless, the Haven has never turned anyone away for lack of space
nor do they plan to start now. (The Haven does not accept people who
are inebriated or appear to be high on drugs or are abusive to other
guests or volunteers -- which is necessary for the comfort and safety
of the other guests and the volunteers.) By the way, about 63 percent
of the funds for the renovations and addition came from federal grants,
about 23 percent from state funds and about 14 percent from the private
sector.
Local clergy in The Valley, staff at the Central Vermont Community Land
Trust, the Central Vermont Community Action Agency, apparently the
social worker in Barre, and most other service providers in the area
are familiar with the Haven. It would seem, however, that Good Sam will
need to toot its horn a bit louder and make sure that its services are
better known to The Valley community at large. Hopefully, this will
help.
Karen Winchell lives in Fayston.
